Groundbreaking Custody
Battle
October 2, 2003
By Jennifer Parker
Komo 1000
News
SEATTLE - A groundbreaking
case that could define who is a parent and who gets
visitation rights to a child heads to a Seattle courtroom
Friday.
Two women and one man all love one child. Now, one of the
women who helped raise the child for her first six years
wants visitation.
In this case two women living together decided to have a
child through artificial insemination. They raised that
child together for 6 years, then they broke up.
According to Nancy Sapiro the attorney for Mian Carvin
(the woman who's not the biological mother), the biological
mother won't let Carvin see the child.
"In January 2002 the biological mother severed all
contact," said Sapiro.
Since then, the biological mother has married the sperm
donor.
When the case went to court a judge found that both
parties care deeply for the child. Court documents say
Carvin "cannot establish parentage because she is neither
the birth mother, nor the donor of the egg or ovum."
The judge went on to say..."The only way a man would have
status as a child's parent, under the facts of this case
would be if he were married to the birth mother of the
child...and there is no common law marriage in Washington."
Carvin could have assured herself partial custody when
she and the defendant were together. Washington state does
not recognize same sex marriage but it does recognize same
sex adoption. Carvin never adopted, but now wants
visitation.
"Adopting is something that when families are together
and you're living together and operating as a family you
don't think of the legal steps one needs to take to secure
your status," said Sapiro.
Friday the Carvin and Saprio will ask the Appelate Court
Judge to put the case back to trial court to start over and
figure out what's in the child's best interest.
KOMO 4 News contacted the defendant's attorney, but our
call was not returned.
We're told it will probably take a few months to get a
decision in the case.